Wednesday, June 15, 2022

Say it again

 They said it: Quotes from the media

   Newspaper stories often contain statements that are worth noting. Here are two from stories about Alison Carey and Mariah Carey.

   The first is from a 2020 story in the British newspaper the The Sun, in which Alison described being taken by her mother, Patricia to terrifying satanic rituals. The story quoted "an insider" saying: 

 “Mariah thrives off all the drama that’s attached to her and always has done. The idea of fading into obscurity is her worst nightmare.”

   The second quote, also in The Sun, was in a story published in 2011, in which Alison commented on Mariah's twins:

   "I cannot put into words how moved I was to see pictures of my niece and nephew for the first time.

  “I saw photographs of them on the television just after they were born and I saw more when they turned 1 recently. They are absolutely adorable.

   "And when I look into their eyes I see my sister's eyes shining right back at me - the eyes I used to stare into when I would hold her as a baby."

*****

Friday, May 27, 2022

Delayed again

 

Dispute over filing statement keeps Morgan Carey's defamation lawsuit against Mariah Carey on hold

By David Baker

Fifteen months after Morgan Carey’s lawsuit against Mariah Carey was filed, the case still is at a point it would normally have been at this time last year.  Delayed first by Mariah’s unsuccessful attempt to get it all thrown out, and then by the filing of an amended complaint, its’s now held up by a dispute over what is usually a routine statement called a verification.

New York state legal rules require that a complaint - the document that starts a lawsuit - includes a “verification”, a single paragraph in which the person filing the lawsuit states under oath that he or she has read the document, and that the allegations in it are true to his or her knowledge. 

It’s a routine part of a complaint. In some cases, the attorney, rather than the plaintiff, can sign the verification, such as when the client does not live in the county when the attorney has his or her office.

Morgan Carey currently resides in Hawaii, so the exception allowing his attorney, Richard A. Altman, to file the verification would apply.

The problem is that the form Altman filed with the complaint  back in March 2021 is worded for a plaintiff, not an attorney; In it, Altman states that the allegations in it are “.. true to [his] own knowledge.” Which, as Mariah Carey’s lawyers pointed out, could not be true unless Altman was a witness to events involving Morgan Carey that Mariah Carey claims occurred more than 40 years ago.

State rules also say that a response to a verified filing must also be verified. But in their long delayed answer, Mariah Carey’s attorneys claim that because the complaint was not properly verified, they do not have to verify their response.

Altman, Morgan Carey’s attorney, responded by saying he considers the answer to be invalid. Pointing out that Mariah Carey’s attorneys waited eight months to object to the allegedly defective complaint, he says his client will ask the court for a default judgment.

The mystery is why Altman didn’t simply have Morgan Carey sign a verification before a notary in Hawaii and send it to Altman, as he did with an affidavit Morgan Carey provided last year.

Not doing that has allowed Mariah Carey’s attorneys to add yet another delay to the case, as the dispute will have to be settled by the judge.

But causing delays - and doing everything possible to run up a plaintiffs costs - is what some wealthy defendants do.

Particularly ones who know that eventually they will probably lose.

********* 

Friday, March 11, 2022

BREAKING NEWS

   
Appeal of judge's ruling could put publishers back into Morgan Carey's lawsuit over sister's memoir

   By David Baker
   Attorneys for Morgan Carey have filed notice that they intend to appeal a judge's decision that removed the publishers and co-writer of the book "The Meaning of Mariah Carey" from Morgan Carey's lawsuit, leaving only the singer to defend claims over statements in the book that Morgan Carey says have damaged him.
   It's not immediately clear if filing of the notice will put on hold discovery in the action against Mariah Carey. Under state Supreme Court Justice Barbara Jaffe's Feb. 15 decision, Mariah Carey's attorney's were ordered to serve an answer to the year-old initial compliant by March 8. Last week, lawyers for both sides agreed to extend that deadline until March 22.
  Morgan Carey's lawsuit, filed on March 3, 2021, named as defendants, Macmillan Publishing Group, doing business as Henry Holt and Co., Andy Cohen Book, and the book's co-writer, Michaela Angela Davis.
****

    

Saturday, March 5, 2022

Postponed again

 A year after filing, attorneys agree to another delay


   By David Baker

   Last month the judge in Morgan Carey’s lawsuit over statements in his sister’s book “The Meaning of Mariah Carey” ordered the singer’s lawyers to serve a document called an answer by March 8.

  Evidently, three weeks was not enough time to draft and serve this routine document.

   An answer is the first response to a complaint, the document that starts a lawsuit, and is normally required to be served within 20 days of receipt of the complaint. 

   That would have been served almost a year ago. But since then the case has been delayed both by Mariah Carey’s unsuccessful attempt to get all claims against her thrown out, and by repeated agreements between lawyers for all sides to postpone deadlines.

  Now there’s a further delay: On March 4, lawyers for both remaining parties signed yet another stipulation, agreeing to move the date the answer was due from March 8 to March 22. 

   In a decision and order dated February 16 state Supreme Court Justice Barbara Jaffe ruled that Morgan Carey had failed to show that the publishers and the book’s co-writer intended to damage him - which is called “actual malice” - and threw out all claims against them, as well as most claims against Mariah Carey.

   But the judge said the singer still must defend statements in the book that would lead readers to conclude that Morgan Carey supplied illegal drugs, and that he had been in prison.

***


COMMENT   

   The publishers of Mariah Carey’s book, Henry Holt & Co. and Andy Cohen Books may or may not have avoided a legal claim; a possible appeal could reverse the judge’s decision to dismiss all claims against them. But morally, surely their decision to publish allegations of criminal conduct against both Morgan Carey and, particularly, Alison Carey without, by their own admission, any attempt to confirm what Mariah Carey told them, is beneath contempt.

   From numerous sources they must or should have known of the trauma inflicted on Alison as a child, and that since 2015,  she has struggled with a devastating brain injury. What kind of people, knowing that, would publish the unsubstantiated claims in the book?

   Heartless, greedy people who published the allegations about Alison, then pushed them out to the media to get attention for their little book, that’s who.

*****

Thursday, February 24, 2022

Commentary

Judge's mixed decision leaves Mariah Carey to defend claims in her brother's lawsuit over book

By David Baker   

   The decision by state Supreme Court Justice Barbara Jaffe to dismiss all Morgan Carey’s claims against the publishers of Mariah Carey’s book while allowing two of the same claims against Mariah Carey to continue is puzzling; It assumes that the publishers didn’t know and couldn’t be expected to know that publishing statements accusing two people of serious crimes without, apparently, any more then a blind belief in their author might make them also liable.

   The ruling comes almost a year after the complaint that started the lawsuit was filed. Since then the defendants have spent thousands of dollars trying to get the case thrown out before it started. For the publishers, it worked - unless an appeal is filed and that part of the decision is reversed. 

   But for Mariah Carey, the case continues, first with the service on Morgan’s attorneys of an answer - a paragraph by paragraph response to the allegations in the complaint, followed by written questions, and then depositions of the plaintiff and defendant.

   It’s at her deposition that defendant Carey will have to account for accusing Morgan of being a “sometimes drug dealing, being-in-the-system, drunk-ass brother.”

   Ironically, it’s likely it wasn’t Carey who came up with that dramatic line, but rather the person she hired to actually write the memoir, Michaela Angela Davis - who last week was removed from Morgan Carey’s lawsuit. Nevertheless, it’s Mariah Carey’s book and she is responsible for everything in it. 

  That includes claiming her sister Alison gave her Valium and offered her cocaine when she was 12 years old and Alison was 20 - both accusations of serious crimes known as defamation per se, meaning that financial loss or other damage doesn’t have to be proved.

   Alison denies it ever happened and says Mariah made up the story about her brain-damaged destitute sister and fed it to the  media in a callous effort to promote her book. 

   So unless Mariah Carey has or can concoct something to support her accusation, the case will be a ‘she said, she said’ battle. Forty years later, how do you prove something didn’t happen? How does Alison prove a negative? 

   Meanwhile, Morgan’s case now moves forward, which, without a settlement, will add to the permanent public record of Mariah Carey’s totally unnecessary cruel attack on her two less fortunate siblings.

*****

Wednesday, February 16, 2022

Decision issued

Mariah Carey now the sole defendant in brother Morgan Carey's lawsuit over singer's memoir

By David Baker

Much of Morgan Carey's lawsuit against his sister Mariah Carey was dismissed on Tuesday but the singer still faces legal proceedings over statements in her book The Meaning Of Mariah Carey that Morgan Carey dealt drugs, and suggested that he had been in prison.

In a 28-page decision, state Supreme Court Justice Barbara Jaffe dismissed all but two of Morgan's claims, along with all claims against the publishers of the book and its co-writer.

All the defendants had asked that the entire case be thrown out.

Mariah Carey's lawyers now have 20 days after service of the decision to respond with what's known as an "answer." After that the discovery process begins, with written questions and depositions of the brother and sister.

The lawsuit was filed almost a year ago, on March 3, 2021. Since then all sides have filed a series of motions and responses. Several agreed postponements of filing deadlines and a backlog in the court system caused by the COVID pandemic has kept the case on hold until now.

*****


Tuesday, February 15, 2022

Final wishes

 End of life will mean decisions for the family; And problems with another government agency

By David Baker

Alison Carey is 60 years old. Her mother, Patricia Carey, turns 85 this week and has been reported to be in declining physical and mental  health.
   Alison realizes that she will probably never see her mother again. She has mixed feelings about that.

  “She is an evil woman,” Alison says. “Nobody should be subjected to what she did to me when I was a child.”

    Alison was referring to being taken by her mother to terrifying 2 a.m. satanic rituals, where she was sexual abused.

   “But she is my mother. Sometimes I think I would like to speak to her, to ask her why she did it.  But most of the time I never want to see her again.”

   Patricia is reportedly living in a high-end facility in Florida with a team of aides to assist her. Alison is not sure that when her mother dies she will be told.

   With her own deteriorating health, Alison also thinks about the end of her life.  She says she often wonders if anyone will be at her funeral. She assumes none of her family members will be there. And certainly it would be the height of hypocrisy of if they attend after ignoring her for the latter part of her life, particularly since 2015 while she has struggled with a serious brain injury that left her with permanent damage to her short-term memory and vision.

   Alison also wonders if the family will pay for her funeral. Coming up with the money after she was gone would also be hypocritical. But refusing to do it would look bad, too. Either way, the decision will likely generate another set of headlines.

*** 

   

Three years ago, all Alison’s teeth had to be removed, and then a set of dentures were broken in a fall. A Go Fund Me page seeking donations has raised $840, far short of the $2,500 needed for a new set. There is no indication that anyone in her family - siblings or offspring - has made a contribution.

***


Back in December, the Social Security Administration got some embarrassing publicity after ignoring for three months Alison’s repeated letters informing the agency that she was living in an apartment, not in a nursing home, and reducing her benefit to $30 a month.

  Now the county department that administers SNAP payments - food stamps - is doing something similar. In a notice sent in January, the department states that Alison’s SNAP benefit is being cut from $250 a month to $25. The reason, the notice says, is that the oil that heats her apartment and her electricity are both included in the rent.

   Both statements are wrong. 

   The notice also says that Alison is entitled to receive copies of the documents on which the decision to cut the benefit was made. A written request for these documents was made last week. So far none have been received.

   Maybe it will take another newspaper story to restore this benefit. 

***

   

Mariah Carey apparently didn’t consider that when she had her memoir written she was also creating her legacy. The book - with its attacks on her brother and sister - and the permanent public record on the Internet and in legal filings will determine how she is viewed long after her career is a fading memory for most people.

   And because of her own actions, much of that legacy will be largely dictated by her tragic and possibly by-then deceased sister and a former journalist from the U.K who was there for Alison when her family turned away.

********


The Go Fund Me page for Alison’s dentures is at: https://gofund.me/9030f169


***